My deconversion, and what led to it

BenfromCanada's picture

In case any of you care.
I was raised in a fairly secular home, though my mother, raised a Catholic (but she fell away from the church because of the Latin masses and the "Mary worship"), would pray with me every night before I slept. I never understood it, though. My first church service was a funeral for my maternal grandmother. All I remember of it was me, as a kid, screaming "open that box, my grandma's in there!" but mom recalls me speaking "like a chipmunk" for about a year afterwards. [likely due to stress] One thing you should know is that rejection and racism occur often in my life, especially early on. My mother's family, outside of her mother, opposed the marriage of their Connie to my half native american father (we thought her adopted brother, Kent, accepted the union as well, but it turned out he was trying to break them up by causing fights between them and sowing seeds of distrust when alone with one of them). The reason was purely racist, didn't want to dilute the bloodline with us damn mixed breeds. As a kid in preschool, I was rejected by other kids, mostly due to my attitude. I was a bit of a jerk, to say the least, which I believe is behaviour I took from my father, an emotional mess and a bit of an abusive person, emotionally. Occasionally physically too. And I'd of course abuse my poor little mentally handicapped brother in turn.

When I began kindergarten, my first (and only) friend was a well-to-do Christian kid named Danny who lived down the block. This was the first time I felt accepted and appreciated by someone other than my mother, so the association between Christianity and Acceptance was forming, and becoming strong. We watched a lot of his Christian videos like Gospel Bill, McGee and Me and Hanna Barbera's bible tales show where three kids went into Bible times...the name escapes me. He also took me to church once, but I came back obsessed with blood. That night when Mom ran my bath I said "No, mommy, not water, blood! I have to be bathed in the blood of the lamb!" or some such, and mom thought it unhealthy. Plus, Danny's mom did something that took collosal cojones. When preparing a guest sermon on Remembrance Day (November 11, I think Americans have a corresponding holiday) she called dad and asked him, since he was a Vietnam Veteran, a few questions about the experience of war. One of them was "what's it like to kill people?" I wasn't told WHY I wasn't allowed to see Danny after that, but I found out about 10 years later when Dad had accepted that Danny was a cool guy, but his mom wasn't. The religion stayed with me, sort of. I even had a prophetic dream that year, where I "predicted" my sister's birth, 6 weeks before mom knew she was pregnant. Jesus led me through a gingerbread house with assembly lines of angels manufacturing babies, and at the end gave me a beautiful little sister named Cyndal. Of course in the dream she was taller than she is now, much more sweet and kind, and has long blonde hair. The fact she was BORN with blonde hair seemed to confirm the prophecy, the fact it fell out soon afterwards due to Alopecia didn't deter me at all, I prophesied something.

I didn't have any experience with religion at all up until the age of about 8, when dad was re-united with his foster mother (one of about 30 foster homes he'd been in was a Salvation Army minister's house, and it was the only one that treated him well. Ironically, when he was sexually abused by a clergyman a year or two after leaving that house, it was a Salvation Army minister.) He'd been taken away after her first husband died, due to a law barring single mothers form having foster kids, and hadn't seen her since the 1960s. I started going to Sunday school, and church, the former of which was fun, the latter of which was boring. I was picked up every Sunday, rode in the old Salvation Army van, and had fun learning about Jesus. I was not serious, though. Meanwhile, kids at school constantly picked on me because my skin was a shade or two darker, and mom urged me to start participating in sports, because I was too "bookish". Well, OK, because she and dad thought I was gay. So of course, with the racism and bullying, I was totally into anything that would make me stronger and more tough. At age 10 I hit puberty, and things really turned around as I was now bigger, more developed muscularly, physically fit, and in karate and boxing. So I started kicking a lot of arses, became a schoolyard bully, while still having my Sunday fun. Juniour Soldiers (mid week Sunday school for pre-teens) started in the middle of the week, and I joined. I was the "rebel" kid there, and thought I was the shit. They actually gave me Jr. Soldier of the year once, which was awesome. This kept up for a few years, until Grade 7, when a kid from Vancouver moved here. I befriended him at first, but we had a falling out. Long story short, first ever attempted murder on a primary school playground in British Columbia, probably first one in Canada. He brought a hunting knife to school (his reasoning being that I once said I'd kill him, which I probably did, but in no way meant it) and we had our daily word-war. That time it turned into a fight between me, Skylar and his one friend, Mark. Teacher broke us up, made us wait outside the Principal's office (actually outside the school, next to the flagpole) and Skylar spit on me a few times. I spit back, he said "I don't care how much trouble I get into for this" brandished the knife, and I jumped back while Mark held him back and talked sense into the 13 year old who was about to kill someone over a soiled jacket. They walked away, I told the teachers what happened, Skylar got suspended for several months (though not expelled until a little later). The fear of death was in me, I accepted Jesus for serious, and actually started caring about religion.

I got "saved" a bunch of times at church, and mom saw the new devotion to Christianity. Knowing that another kid from my school, named Steve, would be going to an A.C.E. (Accelerated Christian Education) private school named Praise Fellowship next year, she signed me up to protect me. Of course, I was in no danger as a restraining order prevented Skylar from attending the same school as me, but mothers are rather overprotective. Praise Fellowship was a very odd time in my life.

Despite having lower numbers, Praise Fellowship actually had a better ratio of non-white to white students (including me, 7 out of the 39 students were something other than white, compared to about 5 of 300+ in my other school). In the previous school I'd attended, Highlands Elementary, I'd experienced racism in minor forms (a few racial slurs here or there, one kid not being allowed to play with me because I was a "stupid indian" but nothing more), in Praise, I'd encounter my first White Supremacist, and my first taste of class warfare. He was a rich kid whose father was donating a lot to the school, so the administrators turned a blind eye to his jackassery. When he assaulted me in gym class, severely bruising my thigh and breaking a hockey stick...nothing. Didn't even have to replace the stick (his dad was paying enough to more than cover it). When he wrote an alternate version of the Book of Revelations, where the Angels of the Lord came down to wipe out the native americans and grind their children into dogfood (in reference to a horrendous act of brutality the Americans committed against a tribe in the Appalachians) and force their parents to eat it "like the dogs they are", he was made to apologize to me personally. After the apology, when he showed me the pictures he drew of the events depicted in his alternate Revelations....nothing. When he physically assaulted one of the other native kids, nephew of the local chief, member of the only influential native family at the time, immediate expulsion. I was kind of sad I wasn't there that day.

Despite the racism and classism I experienced in Praise, I went radically conservative Christian, in accordance with their beliefs. I hated Communists and Evolutionists (VERY ironic, considering that I'm now a socialist and a believer in evolution), felt passionate about Santa Claus trying to take over Christmas, knew all the words to the Canadian Pledge of Allegiance (which they said was banned in public schools here in the 60s, but in reality was never in public schools in Canada...it was a direct plagiarism of the American pledge of allegiance, with "Canada" instead of "United States of America") hated gays, hated the British (because of what I found out they did to the Mohawks...conversely, dad loved the British for how nice they were to us, and hated the French for what they did to the Mohawks, though I didn't mind what the French did as their persecution of us was less severe, and the British were pretty nasty to them here too), hated catholics and atheists and abortionists and people who had pre-marital sex as well as people who didn't put stock in the KJV (yes, it was a KJV only church). While opposing racism, I was becoming a bigot myself. This is around the time the Aryan Nations moved into my area (the bully who got expelled for hitting the rich native kid went and joined them).

The family couldn't afford to keep me in Praise, which was OK by me, I had my faith and was growing displeased with the administration for their complete jackassery. I went to the public school system again next year, was behind a bit because unlike most private schools, Praise was a lower standard than the public schools. Luckily, Skylar had mellowed out a lot so I didn't need to renew the restraining order, and I hooked up with a bible study. I also went to a Foursquare youth group called Hiz House, led by a black guy from the U.S.A. named Ron Parker (the very first night I was accepted like a brother. One of the leaders said to me that night, "in the body of Christ we're all a different part, and I feel like you're a leg, someone we can lean on. I think that if you didn't show up next week, we'd notice your absence," which for a kid who had almost no friends was the best type of message he could get.) I was going to Corps. Cadets (Jr. Soldiers for teenagers) on Wednesdays, Hiz House on Fridays, Hiz House leadership meetings on Saturday afternoons (seriously, this youth group of 170 made me one of their leaders a month after joining, partly because of my intense dedication and partly because Danny was one of the other leaders) bible study during lunch hours on Mondays, church on Sunday, putting on a service for the senior citizens home with the other corps cadets Sunday nights. Then a guy named Ron Short from the Salvation Army wanted to start a weekend youth group for Saturday nights, and wanted me to help in leading it, as I had already decided to be a youth pastor at age 14. This Salvation Army Youth Group turned into a Youth Drop In Centre every night outside of Sunday, and I was there every night except Friday, barring homework. Church, and god, had become my entire life. At the age of 15, it suffered some setbacks, as both Ron Parker and Ron Short had to leave their positions (Parker, married with 2 kids, had a "mutual crush" with a 15 year old girl, which apparently never amounted to anything more, but he was run out of town; Short was caught stealing money from the Sally Ann). Hiz House continued under a different name with different leadership, but it went from 170 to 100 to 70 to 50 to 30, and the Salvation Army Youth Group and Youth Drop In Centre were closed down. I filled the void with Nights Alive and young Life, but it wasn't the same, I didn't feel as accepted. So, of course, I doubted. It didn't last long after some intense prayer and a Franklin Graham revival tour, but I did doubt.

When I made it to High School, I started going to the Christian Centre youth group with Danny, Adam, and a bunch of other friends who were of varying degrees of faith, and kept up the Foursquare and Nights Alive and Young Life and Corps. Cadets. but in my grade 12 year, I moved out of Cranbrook, to Kimberley, so I had to leave all of those behind. I was quite sad, I figured I had lifelong friends at long last (though in fact only Adam is still a friend) and was thrown into a place where no one liked me (Kimberley's a racist hick town and they hate Cranbrook kids more than they hate minorities). I found, however, the closest knit church and youth group ever (there was a co-op between the Pentecostal and Presbyterian church) and I was in heaven. Friends, Jesus, and all that jazz. I kept going to it, and switching between the two churches, all throughout my first 2 years of college. However, in college, I met some intelligent atheists, and actually studied philosophy, so I actually analyzed my faith, and found many, many questions. Where did Cain's wife come from? Why is it that "God always existed" is a fine argument, but "matter and energy always existed" is not? How could Moses have written the Law when he DIED in the second book? If Jesus performed all those miracles, isn't it logical that everyone would have followed him? Why does a loving god still punish us for sins Adam and Eve did, and why was acquiring knowledge a sin at all? Some had adequate answers, most did not. After a year, I'd also come to the conclusion I'd never date Jen from the now-solely Presbyterian youth group. She said she'd never date a non-christian, and overlooked a perfectly good christian (me) for....a non-christian. By this time I was also mellowing out a lot on my hate, watching it dissolve, and in fact, becoming a liberal via Student Government and activism, and education (the more educated I got, the more liberal I got in my faith and in my politics. I convinced myself Jesus would do the same, and were he real, I bet he would). My political awakening opened my eyes to a lot of wrongs the church did, furthering my questioning and causing more doubt. And of course, getting a bit more in touch with my native american roots hurt my faith, as I saw all the systemic abuse the church put us through. But then I met taylor.

I met her in 01 online, loved her a lot. She helped me strengthen my faith a lot. Through thick and thin, we stayed together. Even when I had premarital sex (with someone else, after e-dating her for a while) and got drunk, she kept with me. even when she, a staunch conservative, found out I was a lefty, we were close. I transferred to a christian liberal arts school in Edmonton (King's College University), and she followed. The school both strengthened my faith and weakened it (being around christians helped, but Tay turned out to be a complete nutjob, and no one could answer my questions satisfactorily, except one guy who thought demons were after him because he turned down the job of being the Antichrist. Oh, he and Tay are now married and expecting a baby. Funny how life turns out.) My grades dropped because I stayed up until 5 every goddamned morning convincing her she was a good person and she shouldn't kill herself and blah blah. But we got engaged. She and her mother met my family, and her mother determined that my by now very christian (thanks in part to me) family was all going to hell for...some reason, don't know what. her whole family hated me because I was a liberal, and liberals must be evil. but she still loved me, and I loved her. I had another prophetic dream, where we got married and lived in the Phillipines and ran a missionary hospital, and it turned out to be false, as you can probably guess by her getting married to the Antichrist. So I went totally depressed, and suicidal. I didn't do it, obviously.

But then I began thinking...tay and her family are more godly than I, and they said god didn't want us to be together, and I KNEW that god told me were were to be together forever, so why would god lie to one of us? And I was "healed" by a guy from Tay's church, as was she, and then we were healed again in the Healing Rooms in Spokane, so why didn't we get really healed? I started questioning everything, even more so than I ever had, and even questioned my questions. Was I trying to prove or disprove christianity, rather than find the truth? Were my questions really important, or red herrings? Were the answers I came up with right or wrong, was there a right or wrong answer? Then, a few months after my faith in the institution of the church crumbled completely, since it was man made, I discovered many, many similarities to other mythologies in the OT, and the NT as well. There other myths that shared details with biblical stories predated the bible by centuries, and were from the same area as Israel, so there's a high chance the Hebrews would have known about them. Borrowing from other mythologies was a common thing back in those days, but if these other myths were false and the bible is true, how does it make sense? It doesn't. it was the straw that broke the camel's back. If you want I can show you some of them. Since then I found a few other problems (gross scientific errors that even ancient hebrews should have seen, evidence of massive amounts of forgery and interpolation, especially in the new testament, historical errors in the bible....but you know all of that).
Anyway, when I came out as an atheist to my friends, most of them, treated me quite horribly, which caused some bitterness. When I even hinted at having more faith in evolution or the big bang theory, and when it was discovered that I was reading the holy books of other religions, my family acted very poorly. Much like the crazy catholic mother, though I maintained the lie that I was christian. So, basically, christians in general made me angry, and I was very angry at myself for falling for a lie for so long. I'm over it, mostly. But I'm still critical of the religion. Seriously, its holy book is so very flawed...anyway, that's my history of belief, and why I left the religion. What I believe now? I basically believe that no religion is true. Each one has serious flaws. As such, none work for me. If there is a creator, it doesn't matter, since it never made itself known to us. That's my belief, in a nutshell.
Thank you for your patience.

JCE's picture

I care - WOW!!  Thank you

I care - WOW!!  Thank you so much for sharing your story!  That took a lot of courage to write. 

 

There may already be a thread on this site discussing the comparable mythologies, but if you can't find it please post the myth comparisons you have found.  That stuff is very interesting! 

BenfromCanada's picture

jce wrote: I care - WOW!!

jce wrote:

I care - WOW!! Thank you so much for sharing your story! That took a lot of courage to write.

 

There may already be a thread on this site discussing the comparable mythologies, but if you can't find it please post the myth comparisons you have found. That stuff is very interesting!

Thank you jce. I'm glad you appreciated it. I actually wrote this months ago for a person who asked it of me (took me like, 3 hours when I did write it). I had to edit it a bit, update it slightly, take off a personal message, but otherwise you're reading an e-mail to a friend...well, ex-friend. Shortly after asking me about this stuff, I tried to share with her the myths that I found comparable to Jesus, and she thought I was trying to convert her to atheism...even though she requested them. Crazy people.

Most of the ones I found were in the movie "The God Who Wasn't There", at least in name. The most important omission from that film was Horus, who was halfway referenced in the film. He was the son of the Egyptian god Osiris, come to earth. He did many miracles, including water to wine and raising the dead, and healing. He battled...fuck, I forgot his name. Anyway, he died in this battle, and Isis raised him from the dead to defeat this evil being. Wasn't a 3 day wait, it was less than one day, but he was killed by a spear to the side. He saved the day, and it was then revealed that he was the son of Osiris, and he WAS Osiris. What struck me most was that this character was an Egyptian myth, and that the Hebrews were in Egypt for a while, and were in close proximity to the country, so they would have known this story. Or, at least the educated ones would have. The peasant class would likely have forgotten it by then.

The one that did deconvert me was the Babylonian/Sumerian myths, especially their creation myth (which reads almost identically to the Genesis one, and predates it by hundreds of years). In fact, almost all of Genesis is found in one way or another in Babylonian and Sumerian texts. The Ugaritic Texts are another one, the one that got me on the "bible myth" subject. They are Caananite writings, are also similar to the Old Testament, but they split their god up into many gods, while Abraham's god did the work of all the elohim. He even had the same word for his god as they did for their main god ("El&quotEye-wink. It could be a result of the Hebrews and Caananites having the same root language, but that wouldn't explain the similarities in rituals and the garden/forbidden fruit/snake creation myth.

JCE's picture

I knew there were comparable

I knew there were comparable myths out there but I had not heard of these.  I am getting ready to watch "The God Who Wasn't There" tonight.  It is just so interesting the way these things have evolved!  I would love to see a play-by-play listing for each story in the bible although it is probably quite extensive.  lol

BenfromCanada's picture

jce wrote:

jce wrote:
I knew there were comparable myths out there but I had not heard of these. I am getting ready to watch "The God Who Wasn't There" tonight. It is just so interesting the way these things have evolved! I would love to see a play-by-play listing for each story in the bible although it is probably quite extensive. lol

It would be enough for at least 2 hours, if you were quick about it. Much more if you wanted to include everything. There are even comparable myths in non middle-eastern/arabic countries. Many theorize that Krishna, who was very christ-like, and who came onto the scene over a thousand years before Jesus, is how "Christ" got his name.

Susan's picture

Quite A Story!

That's quite a story, Ben.  Thanks for sharing it.

For years you believed what was fed to you.  Likely some of the willingness to believe was because you were accepted in the group.

Good for you for studying and learning and figuring it out on your own.

I'm so glad you're here! 

Atheist Books, purchases on Amazon support the Rational Response Squad server.

BenfromCanada's picture

Susan wrote: That's quite

Susan wrote:

That's quite a story, Ben. Thanks for sharing it.

For years you believed what was fed to you. Likely some of the willingness to believe was because you were accepted in the group.

Good for you for studying and learning and figuring it out on your own.

I'm so glad you're here!

Thank you Susan. I'm almost 100% certain that the main reason I held on so long was the acceptance. The next biggest one was the rejection I faced from non-christians, due to my being a mindless zealot, and judgemental. Thank god for philosophy classes and science classes and intelligent atheist friends, and liberal politics.

Thank you, Susan. I'm glad I'm here too!

GlamourKat's picture

I am so sorry you had to go

I am so sorry you had to go through all that, and so glad that you're here now to tell us. Good story, and greetings to a fellow BCer. Smiling

 I'm really enjoying all your input on the forum so far! Your posts are pretty fun to read.

BenfromCanada's picture

GlamourKat wrote: I am so

GlamourKat wrote:

I am so sorry you had to go through all that, and so glad that you're here now to tell us. Good story, and greetings to a fellow BCer. Smiling

I'm really enjoying all your input on the forum so far! Your posts are pretty fun to read.

Thank ye Glamour. I thus far enjoy what I've read of your stuff too. I was going to move to Vancouver, but those plans fell through. I do prefer the Coast to my little redneck area of BC...I prefer it a lot, in fact.

Wow

That was really long, but I managed to read through it all.

Really, I've been brought up Christian, but lately my faith has been weakening - I already believe evolution to be incontrovertibly true and have a really hard time reconciling evolution with religion, and www.whywontgodhealamputees.com is making some strong, strong points. I do intend to do further research on other resources to see if anything can (in a rational non-fallacious manner) restore my faith, but by now I might've been pretty full de-converted.

It feels weird, ya know? Losing the "security blanket" of having someone "up there" watching over you, the slight worry that if I'm wrong, I will be forced to roast in bottomless flaming pits for eternity, a fate that not even death can save me from... meh. I suppose religion withdrawal happens to many recent de-converts. I'll get over it, I suppose.

My last thought is, if it turns out I re-covert, I'll still feel very, very sad that when I die, I'll go to heaven while some of my friends and loved ones will have to be the ones burning forever.

JillSwift's picture

LL wrote:That was really

LL wrote:
That was really long, but I managed to read through it all. Really, I've been brought up Christian, but lately my faith has been weakening - I already believe evolution to be incontrovertibly true and have a really hard time reconciling evolution with religion, and www.whywontgodhealamputees.com is making some strong, strong points. I do intend to do further research on other resources to see if anything can (in a rational non-fallacious manner) restore my faith, but by now I might've been pretty full de-converted. It feels weird, ya know?
Yes, we know. Most if not all of the posters here have been through it. We there with ya!    
LL wrote:
Losing the "security blanket" of having someone "up there" watching over you, the slight worry that if I'm wrong, I will be forced to roast in bottomless flaming pits for eternity, a fate that not even death can save me from... meh.
What if you're wrong about Christianity, too? If you find yourself in one of Budhist "hells", or Alisyum, or...    
LL wrote:
I suppose religion withdrawal happens to many recent de-converts. I'll get over it, I suppose. My last thought is, if it turns out I re-covert, I'll still feel very, very sad that when I die, I'll go to heaven while some of my friends and loved ones will have to be the ones burning forever.
Odd thing to say, hmm? Would you realy want to go back to a 'god' who would do such awful things to its creations?

 

 

"Anyone can repress a woman, but you need 'dictated' scriptures to feel you're really right in repressing her. In the same way, homophobes thrive everywhere. But you must feel you've got scripture on your side to come up with the tedious 'Adam and Eve not Adam and Steve' style arguments instead of just recognising that some people are different." - Douglas Murray

Muy bueno

La verdad es que tu historia me pareció impresionante. Sos un buen escritor, además.

 

*Moderator note: Google Translation: Spanish » English  - The truth is that your story struck me as impressive. Sos a good writer, as well.