Atheism and Anger

Silly_Mommy
BloggerSuperfan
Posts: 79
Joined: 2008-08-10
User is offlineOffline
Atheism and Anger

Written beatifully by Greta Christina.

She has said everything I have not always been able to say in many conversations, when all I really wanted to do was bitch slap the idiot I was talking to.

Please enjoy.

And bring booze.

It pisses off the Mormons.

 ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

 

http://gretachristina.typepad.com/greta_christinas_weblog/2007/10/atheists-and-an.html 

I want to talk about atheists and anger.

This has been a hard piece to write, and it may be a hard one to read. I'm not going to be as polite and good-tempered as I usually am in this blog; this piece is about anger, and for once I'm going to fucking well let myself be angry.

But I think it's important. One of the most common criticisms lobbed at the newly-vocal atheist community is, "Why do you have to be so angry?" So I want to talk about:

1. Why atheists are angry;

2. Why our anger is valid, valuable, and necessary;

And 3. Why it's completely fucked-up to try to take our anger away from us.

So let's start with why we're angry. Or rather -- because this is my blog and I don't presume to speak for all atheists -- why I'm angry.

*****


GraphI'm angry that according to a recent Gallup poll, only 45 percent of Americans would vote for an atheist for President.

I'm angry that atheist conventions have to haveextra security, including hand-held metal detectors and bag searches, because of fatwas and death threats.

SoldiersI'm angry that atheist soldiers -- in the U.S. armed forces -- have had prayer ceremonies pressured on them and atheist meetings broken up by Christian superior officers, in direct violation of the First Amendment. I'm angry that evangelical Christian groups are being given exclusive access to proselytize on military bases -- again in the U.S. armed forces, again in direct violation of the First Amendment. I'm angry that atheist soldiers who are complaining about this are being harassed and are even getting death threatsfrom Christian soldiers and superior officers -- yet again, in the U.S. armed forces. And I'm angry that Christians still say smug, sanctimonious things like, "there are no atheists in foxholes." You know why you're not seeing atheists in foxholes? Because believers are threatening to shoot them if they come out.

George_h_w_bushI'm angry that the 41st President of the United States, George Herbert Walker Bush, said of atheists, in my lifetime, "No, I don't know that atheists should be regarded as citizens, nor should they be regarded as patriotic. This is one nation under God." My President. No, I didn't vote for him, but he was still my President, and he still said that my lack of religious belief meant that I shouldn't be regarded as a citizen.

JuryI'm angry that it took until 1961 for atheists to be guaranteed the right to serve on juries, testify in court, or hold public office in every state in the country.

CreationismI'm angry that almost half of Americans believe in creationism. And not a broad, "God had a hand in evolution" creationism, but a strict, young-earth, "God created man pretty much in his present form at one time within the last 10,000 years" creationism.

Origin_of_speciesAnd on that topic: I'm angry that school boards all across this country are still -- 82 years after the Scopes trial -- having to spend time and money and resources on the fight to have evolution taught in the schools. School boards are not exactly loaded with time and money and resources, and any of the time/ money/ resources that they're spending fighting this stupid fight is time/ money/ resources that they're not spending, you know, teaching.

Condom_packageI'm angry that women are dying of AIDS in Africa and South America because the Catholic Church has convinced them that using condoms makes baby Jesus cry.

Coat_hangerI'm angry that women are having septic abortions -- or are being forced to have unwanted children who they resent and mistreat -- because religious organizations have gotten laws passed making abortion illegal or inaccessible.

GalileoI'm angry about what happened to Galileo. Still. And I'm angry that it took the Catholic Church until 1992 to apologize for it.

Christian_marriageI get angry when advice columnists tell their troubled letter-writers to talk to their priest or minister or rabbi... when there is absolutely no legal requirement that a religious leader have any sort of training in counseling or therapy.

BibleAnd I get angry when religious leaders offer counseling and advice to troubled people -- sex advice, relationship advice, advice on depression and stress, etc. -- not based on any evidence about what actually does and does not work in people's brains and lives, but on the basis of what their religious doctrine tells them God wants for us.

FistI'm angry at preachers who tell women in their flock to submit to their husbands because it's the will of God, even when their husbands are beating them within an inch of their lives.

Shopping_listI'm angry that so many believers treat prayer as a sort of cosmic shopping list for God. I'm angry that believers pray to win sporting events, poker hands, beauty pageants, and more. As if they were the center of the universe, as if God gives a shit about who wins the NCAA Final Four -- and as if the other teams/ players/ contestants weren't praying just as hard.

CaduceusI'm especially angry that so many believers treat prayer as a cosmic shopping list when it comes to health and illness. I'm angry that this belief leads to the revolting conclusion that God deliberately makes people sick so they’ll pray to him to get better. And I'm angry that theyfoist this belief on sick and dying children -- in essence teaching them that, if they don't get better, it's their fault. That they didn't pray hard enough, or they didn't pray right, or God just doesn't love them enough.

Praying_handsAnd I get angry when other believers insist that the cosmic shopping list isn't what religion and prayer are reallyabout; that their own sophisticated theology is the true understanding of God. I get angry when believers insist that the shopping list is a straw man, an outmoded form of religion and prayer that nobody takes seriously, and it's absurd for atheists to criticize it.

Virginia_techI get angry when believers use terrible, grief-soaked tragedies as either opportunities to toot their own horns and talk about how wonderful their God and their religion are... or as opportunities to attack and demonize atheists and secularism.

BlanketsI'm angry at the Sunday school teacher who told comic artist Craig Thompson that hecouldn't draw in heaven. And I'm angry that she said it with the complete conviction of authority... when in fact she had no basis whatsoever for that assertion. How the hell did she know what Heaven was like? How could she possibly know that you could sing in heaven but not draw? And why the hell would you say something that squelching and dismissive to a talented child?

Mother_teresa_missionary_positionI'm angry that Mother Teresa took her personal suffering and despair at her lost faith in God, and turned it into an obsession that led her to treat suffering as a beautiful gift from Christ to humanity, a beautiful offering from humanity to God, and a necessary part of spiritual salvation. And I'm angry that this obsession apparently led her to offer grotesquely inadequate medical care and pain relief at her hospitals and hospices, in essence taking her personal crisis of faith out on millions of desperately poor and helpless people.

Presbyterian_churchI'm angry at the trustee of the local Presbyterian church who told his teenage daughter that he didn't actually believe in God or religion, but that it was important to keep up his work because without religion there would be no morality in the world.

Hellfire_2I'm angry that so many parents and religious leaders terrorize children -- who (a) have brains that are hard-wired to trust adults and believe what they're told, and (b) are very literal-minded -- with vivid, traumatizing stories of eternal burning and torture to ensure that they'll be too frightened to even question religion.

HellfireI'm angrier when religious leaders explicitly tell children – and adults, for that matter -- that the very questioning of religion and the existence of hell is a dreadful sin, one that will guarantee them that hell is where they'll end up.

Female_reproductive_systemI'm angry that children get taught by religion to hate and fear their bodies and their sexuality. And I'm especially angry that female children get taught by religion to hate and fear their femaleness, and that queer children get taught by religion to hate and fear their queerness.

Candy_caneI'm angry about the Muslim girl in the public school who was told -- by her public-school, taxpayer-paid teacher -- that the red stripes on Christmas candy canes represented Christ's blood, that she had to believe in and be saved by Jesus Christ or she'd be condemned to hell, and that if she didn't, there was no place for her in his classroom. And I'm angry that he told her not to come back to his class when she didn't convert.

PopeI'm angry -- enraged -- at the priests who molest children and tell them it's God's will. I'm enraged at the Catholic Church that consciously, deliberately, repeatedly, for years, acted to protect priests who molested children, and consciously and deliberately acted to keep it a secret, placing the Church's reputation as a higher priority than, for fuck's sake, children not being molested. And I'm enraged that the Church is now trying to argue, in court, that protecting child-molesting priests from prosecution, and shuffling those priests from diocese to diocese so they can molest kids in a whole new community that doesn't yet suspect them, is aConstitutionally protected form of free religious expression.

911I'm angry about 9/11.

Jerry_falwellAnd I'm angry that Jerry Falwell blamed 9/11 on pagans, abortionists, feminists, gays and lesbians, the ACLU, and the People For the American Way. I'm angry that the theology of a wrathful God exacting revenge against pagans and abortionists by sending radical Muslims to blow up a building full of secretaries and investment bankers... this was a theology held by a powerful, widely-respected religious leader with millions of followers.

Brain_mrisvgI'm angry that, when my dad had a stroke and went into a nursing home, the staff asked my brother, "Is he a Baptist or a Catholic?" And I'm not just angry on behalf of my atheist dad. I'm angry on behalf of all the Jews, all the Buddhists, all the Muslims, all the neo-Pagans, whose families almost certainly got asked that same question. That question is enormously disrespectful, not just of my dad's atheism, but of everyone at that nursing home who wasn't a Baptist or a Catholic.

Dore_heavenI'm angry about Ingrid's grandparents. I'm angry that their fundamentalism was such a huge source of strife and unhappiness in her family, that it alienated them so drastically from their children and grandchildren. I'm angry that they tried to cram it down Ingrid's throat, to the point that she's still traumatized by it. And I'm angry that their religion, which if nothing else should have been a comfort to them in their old age, was instead a source of anguish and despair -- because they knew their children and grandchildren were all going to be burned and tortured forever in Hell, and how could Heaven be Heaven if their children and grandchildren were being eternally burned and tortured in Hell?

AisleI'm angry that Ingrid and I can't get legally married in this country -- or get legally married in another country and have it recognized by this one -- largely because religious leaders oppose it. And I'm angry that both religious and political leaders have discovered that they can score big points exploiting people's fears about sexuality in a changing world, fanning the flames of those fears... and giving people a religious excuse for why their fears are justified.

Stem_cell_division_and_differentiatI'm angry that huge swaths of public policy in this country -- not just on same-sex marriage, but on abortion and stem-cell research and sex education in schools -- are being based, not on evidence of which policies do and don't work and what is and isn't true about the world, but onreligious texts written hundreds or thousands of years ago, and on their own personal feelings about how those texts should be interpreted, with no supporting evidence whatsoever -- and no apparent concept of why any evidence should be needed. 

MartinlutherkingI get angry when believers trumpet every good thing that's ever been done in the name of religion as a reason why religion is a force for good... and then, when confronted with the horrible evils done in religion's name, say that those evils weren't done because of religion, were done because of politics of greed or fear or whatever, would have been done anyway even without religion, and shouldn't be counted as religion's fault. (Of course, to be fair, I also get angry when atheists do the opposite: chalk up every evil thing done in the name of religion as a black mark on religion's record, but then insist that the good things were done for other reasons and would have been done anyway, etc. Neither side gets to have it both ways.)

Jesus_fish_eating_darwin_fishI'm angry at the believers who put decals on their cars with a Faith fish eating a Darwin fish... and who think that's clever, who think that religious faith really should triumph over science and evidence. I'm angry at believers who have so little respect for the physical world their God supposedly created that they feel perfectly content to ignore the mountains of physical evidence piling up around them about that real world; perfectly content to see that world as somehow less real and true than their personal opinions about God.

(Note: The litany of specific grievances is now more than halfway over. Analysis of why anger is necessary and valuable is coming up soon. Promise.)


Ted_haggardI get angry when religious leaders opportunistically use religion, and people's trust and faith in religion, to steal, cheat, lie, manipulate the political process, take sexual advantage of their followers, and generally behave like the scum of the earth. I get angry when it happens over and over and over again. And I get angry when people see this happening and still say that atheism is bad because, without religion, people would have no basis for morality or ethics, and no reason not to just do whatever they wanted.

Sold_my_soul_on_ebayI get angry when religious believers make arguments against atheism -- and make accusations against atheists -- without having bothered to talk to any atheists or read any atheist writing. I get angry when they trot out the same old "Atheism is a nihilistic philosophy, with no joy or meaning to life and no basis for morality or ethics"... when if they spent ten minutes in the atheist blogosphere, they would discover countless atheists who experience great joy and meaning in their lives, and are intensely concerned about right and wrong.

Bible_3I get angry when believers use the phrase "atheist fundamentalist" without apparently knowing what the word "fundamentalist" means. Call people pig-headed, call them stubborn, call them snarky, call them intolerant even. But unless you can point to the text to which these "fundamentalist" atheists literally and strictly adhere without question, then please shut the hell up about us being fundamentalist.

Thinking_hunchI get angry when religious believers base their entire philosophy of life on what is, at best, a hunch; when they ignore or reject or rationalize any evidence that contradicts that hunch or calls it into question... and then accuse atheists of being close-minded and ignoring the obvious truth.

PrayerAnd I get angry when believers glorify religious faith without evidence as a positive virtue, a character trait that makes people good and noble... and then continue to accuse atheists of being close-minded and ignoring the obvious truth.

HeartI get angry when believers say that they can know the truth -- the greatest truth of all about the nature of the universe, namely the source of all existence -- simply by sitting quietly and listening to their heart... and then accuse atheists of being arrogant. (This isn't just arrogant towards atheists and naturalists, either. It's arrogant towards people of other religions who have sat just as quietly, listened to their hearts with just as much sincerity, and come to completely opposite conclusions about God and the soul and the universe.)

GalaxyAnd I get angry when believers say that the entire unimaginable enormity of the universe was made solely and specifically for the human race -- when atheists, by contrast, say that humanity is a microscopic dot on a microscopic dot, an infinitesimal eyeblink in the vastness of time and space -- and yet again, believers accuse atheists of being arrogant.

Brain_2I get angry when believers say things like, "Yes, of course, the human mind isn't perfect, we see what we expect to see, we see faces and patterns and intention when they aren't necessarily there... but that couldn't be happening with me. The patterns I see in my life... they couldn't possibly be coincidence or confirmation bias. I'm definitely seeing the hand of God." (And then, once again, those same believers accuse atheists of being close-minded and only seeing what we want to see.)

Man_using_microscopeI get angry when believers treat the gaps in science and scientific knowledge as somehow proof of the existence of God. I get angry when, despite a thousands-of-years-old pattern ofsupernatural explanations being consistently and repeatedly replaced with natural ones, they still think every single unexplained phenomenon can be best explained by God. And I'm angry that, whenever a gap in our knowledge does get filled in, believers either try to suppress it (see above re: evolution in the schools), or else say, "Okay, that part of the world isn't supernatural... but what about this gap over here? Can you explain that, Mr. Smarty-Pants Scientist? You can't! It must be God!"

ArgueI get angry when believers say at the beginning of an argument that their belief is based on reason and evidence, and at the end of the argument say things like, "It just seems that way to me," or, "I feel it in my heart"... as if that were a clincher. I mean, couldn't they have said that at the beginning of the argument, and not wasted my fucking time? My time is valuable and increasingly limited, and I have better things to do with it than debating with people who pretend to care about evidence and reason but ultimately don't.

Bible_magnifying_glassI'm angry that I have to know more about their fucking religion than the believers do. I get angry when believers say things about the tenets and texts of their religion that are flatly untrue, and I have to correct them on it.

IntoleranceI get angry when believers treat any criticism of their religion -- i.e., pointing out that their religion is a hypothesis about the world and a philosophy of it, and asking it to stand up on its own in the marketplace of ideas -- as insulting and intolerant. I get angry when believers accuse atheists of being intolerant for saying things like, "I don't agree with you," "I think you're mistaken about that," "That doesn't make any sense," "I think that position is morally indefensible," and "What evidence do you have to support that?"

Joan_of_arc_burning_at_stakeAnd on that point: I get angry when Christians in the United States -- members of the single most powerful and influential religious group in the country, in the wealthiest and most powerful country in the world -- act like beleaguered victims, martyrs being thrown to the lions all over again, whenever anyone criticizes them or they don't get their way.

True_faithI get angry when believers respond to some or all of these offenses by saying, "Well, that's not the true faith. Hating queers/ rejecting science/ stifling questions and dissent... that's not the true faith. People who do that aren't real (Christians/ Jews/ Muslims/ Hindus/ etc.)." As if they had a fucking pipeline to God. As if they had any reason at all to think that they know for sure what God wants, and that the billions of others who disagree with them just obviously have it wrong. (Besides -- I'm an atheist. The "They just aren't doing religion right" argument is not going to cut it with me. I don't think any of you have it right. To me, it all looks like something that people just made up.)

Jesus_healingOn that topic: I get angry when religious believers insist that their interpretation of their religion and religious text is the right one, and that fellow believers with an opposite interpretation clearly have it wrong. I get angry when believers insist that the parts about Jesus's prompt return and all prayers being answered are obviously not meant literally... but the parts about hell and damnation and gay sex being an abomination, that's real. And I get angry when believers insist that the parts about hell and damnation and gay sex being an abomination aren't meant literally, but the parts about caring for the poor are really what God meant. How the hell do they know which parts of the Bible/ Torah/ Koran/ Bhagavad-Gita/ whatever God really meant, and which parts he didn't? And if they don't know, if they're just basing it on their own moral instincts and their own perceptions of the world, then on what basis are they thinking that God and their sacred texts have anything to do with it at all? What right do they have to act as if their opinion is the same as God's and he's totally backing them up on it?

Saint_patricks_cathedralAnd I get angry when believers act as if these offenses aren't important, because "Not all believers act like that. I don't act like that." As if that fucking matters. This stuff is a major way that religion plays out in our world, and it makes me furious to hear religious believers try to minimize it because it's not how it happens to play out for them. It's like a white person responding to an African-American describing their experience of racism by saying, "But I'm not a racist." If you're not a racist, then can you shut the hell up for ten seconds and listen to the black people talk? And if you’re not bigoted against atheists and are sympathetic to us, then can you shut the hell up for ten seconds and let us tell you about what the world is like for us, without getting all defensive about how it's not your fault? When did this international conversation about atheism and religious oppression become all about you and your hurt feelings?

ScreamingBut perhaps most of all, I get angry -- sputteringly, inarticulately, pulse-racingly angry -- when believers chide atheists for being so angry. "Why do you have to be so angry all the time?" "All that anger is so off-putting." "If atheism is so great, then why are so many of you so angry?"

Which brings me to the other part of this little rant: Why atheist anger is not only valid, but valuable and necessary.

*****

There's actually a simple, straightforward answer to this question:

Because anger is always necessary.

Womanpower_emblemsvgBecause anger has driven every major movement for social change in this country, and probably in the world. The labor movement, the civil rights movement, the women's suffrage movement, the modern feminist movement, the gay rights movement, the anti-war movement in the Sixties, the anti-war movement today, you name it... all of them have had, as a major driving force, a tremendous amount of anger. Anger over injustice, anger over mistreatment and brutality, anger over helplessness.

March_on_washington_aug_28_1963I mean, why the hell else would people bother to mobilize social movements? Social movements are hard. They take time, they take energy, they sometimes take serious risk of life and limb, community and career. Nobody would fucking bother if they weren't furious about something. 

SlingshotSo when you tell an atheist (or for that matter, a woman or a queer or a person of color or whatever) not to be so angry, you are, in essence, telling us to disempower ourselves. You're telling us to lay down one of the single most powerful tools we have at our disposal. You're telling us to lay down a tool that no social change movement has ever been able to do without. You're telling us to be polite and diplomatic, when history shows that polite diplomacy in a social change movement works far, far better when it's coupled with passionate anger. In a battle between David and Goliath, you're telling David to put down his slingshot and just... I don't know. Gnaw Goliath on the ankles or something.

Molotov_cocktailI'll acknowledge that anger is a difficult tool in a social movement. A dangerous one even. It can make people act rashly; it can make it harder to think clearly; it can make people treat potential allies as enemies. In the worst-case scenario, it can even lead to violence. Anger is valid, it's valuable, it's necessary... but it can also misfire, and badly.

PreacherBut unless we're actually endangering or harming somebody, it is not up to believers to tell atheists when we should and should not use this tool. It is not up to believers to tell atheists that we're going too far with the anger and need to calm down. Any more than it's up to white people to say it to black people, or men to say it to women, or straights to say it to queers. When it comes from believers, it's not helpful. It's patronizing. It comes across as another attempt to defang us and shut us up. And it's just going to make us angrier.

Yellow_lineAnd when believers tell passionate, angry atheists that extremism is never right and the truth usually lies somewhere in the middle, they're making a big, big mistake. Not just because they're making us want to spit in their eye. They're making a mistake because they're simply mistaken. Read this piece from Daylight Atheism on The Golden Mean. Read the quotes from the abolitionist movement, the civil rights movement, the anti-war movement, the American Revolution. And then come tell me that the moderate position is usually the right one.

PerspectiveAnd you know what else? I think we need to have some goddamn perspective about this anger business. I mean, I look at organized Christianity in this country -- not just the religious right, but some more "moderate" churches as well -- interfering with AIDS prevention efforts, trying to get their theology into the public schools, actively trying to prevent me and Ingrid from getting legally married, and pulling all the other shit I talk about in this piece.

And I look at atheists sometimes being mean-spirited and snarky in blogs and books and magazines.

And I think, Can we please have some goddamn perspective? 

Computer_keyboardBecause the other thing I'm angry about is the fact that, in this piece, I've touched on -- maybe -- a hundredth of everything that angers me about religion. This piece barely scratches the surface. I know, almost without a doubt, that within five minutes of hitting "Post" and putting this piece on my blog, I'll think of six different things that I'd wished I'd put in. I could write an entire book about everything that angers me about religion -- other people certainly have -- and still not be finished.

ScalesAre you really looking at all of this shit I'm talking about, a millennia-old history of abuse and injustice, deceit and willful ignorance -- and then on the other hand, looking at a couple of years of atheists being snarky on the Internet -- and seeing the two as somehow equivalent? Or worse, seeing the snarky atheists as the greater problem?

If you're doing that, then with all due respect, you can blow me.

We now return you to your regularly scheduled attempts at civility.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~


thatonedude
Superfan
Posts: 327
Joined: 2008-01-15
User is offlineOffline
One comment: fuck yeah!

One comment: fuck yeah!

EDIT: My playlist flipped to Pantera's "Five Minutes Alone" while reading this. How appropriate.

All that is necessary for the triumph of good is that evil men do nothing.


Cpt_pineapple
atheist
Cpt_pineapple's picture
Posts: 5487
Joined: 2007-04-12
User is offlineOffline
For those that say that the

For those that say that the moderates are just standing by:

 

 

 

Constitutional rights/seperation of Church and state

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Barry_W._Lynn

http://www.au.org/site/PageServer

 

Religious right attack on Science/push on creationism.

 

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kenneth_R._Miller

 

 

Islamic terrorism

 

http://www.m-a-t.org/

 

 

Abortion rights [Though I personally disagree with them]

http://www.ffrf.org/nontracts/abortion.php

Do Churches Support Abortion Rights?

Numerous Christian denominations and religious groups agree that the bible does not condemn abortion and that abortion should continue to be legal. These include:

  • American Baptist Churches-USA
  • American Ethical Union
  • American Friends (Quaker) Service Committee
  • American Jewish Congress
  • Christian Church (Disciples of Christ)
  • Episcopal Church
  • Lutheran Women's Caucus
  • Moravian Church in America-Northern Province
  • Presbyterian Church (USA)
  • Reorganized Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints
  • Union of American Hebrew Congregations
  • Unitarian Universalist Association
  • United Church of Christ
  • United Methodist Church
  • United Synagogue of America
  • Women's Caucus Church of the Brethren
  • YWCA
  • Religious Coalition for Reproductive Choice
  • Catholics for Free Choice
  • Evangelicals for Choice

 

 

Just to name a view

 

 

Side note:

Quote:

(Of course, to be fair, I also get angry when atheists do the opposite: chalk up every evil thing done in the name of religion as a black mark on religion's record, but then insist that the good things were done for other reasons and would have been done anyway, etc. Neither side gets to have it both ways.)

 

And it's about fucking time

 

 

 

 

 


thatonedude
Superfan
Posts: 327
Joined: 2008-01-15
User is offlineOffline
Cpt_pineapple wrote:For

Cpt_pineapple wrote:

For those that say that the moderates are just standing by:

I personally work with moderates when our interests coincide, and I don't deny that theists do good in this world. However, I believe that moderate religions still spawn extremist offshoots, and give otherwise irrational beliefs a veneer of respectibility. Hence, my opposition. If religions could be neutered to the point of not affecting my life, I'd be happy to let things go, but I doubt that that is possible.

All that is necessary for the triumph of good is that evil men do nothing.


neptewn
Silver Member
neptewn's picture
Posts: 296
Joined: 2007-06-25
User is offlineOffline
MAPD (Mothers Agaisnt

MAPD (Mothers Agaisnt Praying & Driving)

It's okay to pray, just don't pray and drive.

Your mind will answer most questions if you learn to relax and wait for the answer. - William S. Burroughs


ragdish
atheist
ragdish's picture
Posts: 462
Joined: 2007-12-31
User is offlineOffline
But does anger really help?

Atheism never has nor ever will be a mass movement. Atheists do not share a common ideology. The feminist, Germaine Greer and porn producer Larry Flynt are both atheists and in all likelihood their anger will be directed towards each other. There will never be an atheist march on Washington similar to the civil rights movement, anti-Vietnam protests, gay rights or the women's liberation movement.

Even the porn appreciating Greta Christina would receive vitriol from her atheist antiporn feminist counterparts.

All atheists can do is uphold freedom of speech so that their voices are constantly heard and consciences raised. And that includes the voices of both Germaine Greer and Larry Flynt. Then a critical mass of atheists will develop who will meaningfully participate in shaping this nation towards a society free of irrational supernatural beliefs.


ProzacDeathWish
atheist
ProzacDeathWish's picture
Posts: 3686
Joined: 2007-12-02
User is offlineOffline
Cpt_pineapple wrote:(Of

Cpt_pineapple wrote:

(Of course, to be fair, I also get angry when atheists do the opposite: chalk up every evil thing done in the name of religion as a black mark on religion's record, but then insist that the good things were done for other reasons and would have been done anyway, etc. Neither side gets to have it both ways.)

Cpt_pineapple wrote:

And it's about fucking time

 

                            Bitter ? 

"Most people are ass holes." Jesus of Nazareth


Hambydammit
High Level DonorModeratorRRS Core Member
Hambydammit's picture
Posts: 8657
Joined: 2006-10-22
User is offlineOffline
 I'm always happy to know

 I'm always happy to know when there are enlightened theists whose opinions on politics mirror mine.  They're still being part of the problem, though.  The problem isn't the political stance they take.  It's the foundation of their worldview.

I certainly hope you're not including me among the atheists who claim every bad thing was religion's fault and every good thing was something else.  I've explicitly denied this many, many times.  I do believe that the vast majority of people would still do good things with or without religion, and that the majority is so overwhelmingly large that the loss of altruistic motivation if religion disappeared would be far outweighed by the gain of widespread rationality.  Still, I would never make such a categorical statement.

Out of curiosity, what atheist of note do you know of who says that religion doesn't ever inspire people to good acts, or that religion should be blamed for every evil committed by a religious person?

 

Atheism isn't a lot like religion at all. Unless by "religion" you mean "not religion". --Ciarin

http://hambydammit.wordpress.com/
Books about atheism


Silly_Mommy
BloggerSuperfan
Posts: 79
Joined: 2008-08-10
User is offlineOffline
ragdish wrote:Atheism never

ragdish wrote:

Atheism never has nor ever will be a mass movement. Atheists do not share a common ideology. The feminist, Germaine Greer and porn producer Larry Flynt are both atheists and in all likelihood their anger will be directed towards each other. There will never be an atheist march on Washington similar to the civil rights movement, anti-Vietnam protests, gay rights or the women's liberation movement.

Even the porn appreciating Greta Christina would receive vitriol from her atheist antiporn feminist counterparts.

All atheists can do is uphold freedom of speech so that their voices are constantly heard and consciences raised. And that includes the voices of both Germaine Greer and Larry Flynt. Then a critical mass of atheists will develop who will meaningfully participate in shaping this nation towards a society free of irrational supernatural beliefs.

It's simply a nice thought though. As the parent of a young child, I'm constantly looking for other adults with children who have more intelligence than a moose. And the worst part is that you are purposefully alienated for not being a Christian, or at least pretending to be one.

At the risk of sounding like the ugly girl with braces sitting in the corner seething at the cheerleaders, just understand that it's more about relating to people locally who don't just stare at you and moisten their eyeballs when you say anything other than, "Sheesh, talk about the economy!" I mean, I loved what Greta spoke about, and I really do agree with a lot of what she said, but mine also includes what I wrote above.


Cpt_pineapple
atheist
Cpt_pineapple's picture
Posts: 5487
Joined: 2007-04-12
User is offlineOffline
ProzacDeathWish wrote: 

ProzacDeathWish wrote:

  Bitter ? 

 

Rather.

 

 

Hambydammit wrote:

Out of curiosity, what atheist of note do you know of who says that religion doesn't ever inspire people to good acts, or that religion should be blamed for every evil committed by a religious person?

 

 

 

Harris, Stegner, Hitchens, and of course those atheists who just back down and back peddle when confronted by it.

 

 

 

 

 

 


butterbattle
ModeratorSuperfan
butterbattle's picture
Posts: 3719
Joined: 2008-09-12
User is offlineOffline
Cpt_pineapple wrote:Harris,

Cpt_pineapple wrote:

Harris, Stegner, Hitchens, and of course those atheists who just back down and back peddle when confronted by it.

Um, I don't think that's correct.....

 

Our revels now are ended. These our actors, | As I foretold you, were all spirits, and | Are melted into air, into thin air; | And, like the baseless fabric of this vision, | The cloud-capped towers, the gorgeous palaces, | The solemn temples, the great globe itself, - Yea, all which it inherit, shall dissolve, | And, like this insubstantial pageant faded, | Leave not a rack behind. We are such stuff | As dreams are made on, and our little life | Is rounded with a sleep. - Shakespeare


HisWillness
atheistRational VIP!
HisWillness's picture
Posts: 4100
Joined: 2008-02-21
User is offlineOffline
To be fair to our dear

To be fair to our dear Captain, Hitchens is clearly anti-theistic. On the other hand, his challenge has gone unanswered: "Think of a good thing that would only be done by a person of belief. Now think of a bad thing that would only be done by a person of belief."

The first one is still up for grabs, but the second one is easy.

I'm not sure about the back-peddling, though.

Saint Will: no gyration without funkstification.
fabulae! nil satis firmi video quam ob rem accipere hunc mi expediat metum. - Terence


thatonedude
Superfan
Posts: 327
Joined: 2008-01-15
User is offlineOffline
HisWillness wrote:To be fair

HisWillness wrote:

To be fair to our dear Captain, Hitchens is clearly anti-theistic. On the other hand, his challenge has gone unanswered: "Think of a good thing that would only be done by a person of belief. Now think of a bad thing that would only be done by a person of belief."

The first one is still up for grabs, but the second one is easy.

I'm not sure about the back-peddling, though.

I think that the back-peddling probably refers to the athiests on this site. I've never seen Hitchens, for example, back peddle.

All that is necessary for the triumph of good is that evil men do nothing.


Vastet
atheistBloggerHigh Level ModeratorSuperfan
Vastet's picture
Posts: 10688
Joined: 2006-12-25
User is offlineOffline
That was an excellent

That was an excellent read.

Quote:
(Of course, to be fair, I also get angry when atheists do the opposite: chalk up every evil thing done in the name of religion as a black mark on religion's record, but then insist that the good things were done for other reasons and would have been done anyway, etc. Neither side gets to have it both ways.)

Bua ha ha. I am guilty of this. However, I am aware that I'm guilty of this. Generally I only start throwing this out when its clear that the opponent isn't paying attention or actually contributing to the discussion, at which point I feel free to hit 'em with everything I have. Which is twice as much as they have to work with, since I have all their arguments in reverse as well as all of my own.

This is why I never lose a debate with a theist. They have half of the ammunition they would need to succeed.

Proud Canadian, Enlightened Atheist, Gaming God.


Silly_Mommy
BloggerSuperfan
Posts: 79
Joined: 2008-08-10
User is offlineOffline
Vastet wrote:Bua ha ha. I am

Vastet wrote:

Bua ha ha. I am guilty of this. However, I am aware that I'm guilty of this. Generally I only start throwing this out when its clear that the opponent isn't paying attention or actually contributing to the discussion, at which point I feel free to hit 'em with everything I have. Which is twice as much as they have to work with, since I have all their arguments in reverse as well as all of my own.

This is why I never lose a debate with a theist. They have half of the ammunition they would need to succeed.

 

"I'm angry that I have to know more about their fucking religion than the believers do. I get angry when believers say things about the tenets and texts of their religion that are flatly untrue, and I have to correct them on it."  <--- This part usually tends to make the Atheist argument even more pursuasive. Although I do despise that on personal church documentaries the leaders often find a person who has claimed Atheism but mostly certainly did so without thought or understanding what it meant. There was a video that was particularly vomitous that I witnessed of a group of "teen missionaries - skateboarding for the lord" and all that other bullcrap. They found a random "Atheist kid" (some 16-year-old punk kid who called himself an Atheist because that meant he wasn't conforming with society) that they eventually broke down to pray and come to church them.

That's like Kirk Cameron saying he was a former Atheist.

Pisses me off.


Hambydammit
High Level DonorModeratorRRS Core Member
Hambydammit's picture
Posts: 8657
Joined: 2006-10-22
User is offlineOffline
 Quote:Harris, Stegner,

 

Quote:
Harris, Stegner, Hitchens, and of course those atheists who just back down and back peddle when confronted by it.

Horseshit.

I've stood in the same room with Hitchens while he said that some religious people do good things in the name of religion.  He adds the same caveat that I do -- any good that comes from religion is far outweighed by the bad.  Harris says the same things.  I don't know about Stenger, to be honest.  Could you please provide a quote from Stenger to the effect that nobody ever does anything good because of religion?

 

 

Atheism isn't a lot like religion at all. Unless by "religion" you mean "not religion". --Ciarin

http://hambydammit.wordpress.com/
Books about atheism


Brian37
atheistSuperfan
Brian37's picture
Posts: 13768
Joined: 2006-02-14
User is onlineOnline
Thank you for printing this

Thank you for printing this post. I am surrounded outside the net, in real life by theists and to know that I am not the only one, really helps.

 

"We are a nation of Christians and Muslims, Jews and Hindus -- and nonbelievers."Obama
Check out my poetry here on Rational Responders Like my poetry thread on Facebook under BrianJames Rational Poet also on twitter under Brianrrs37


Brian37
atheistSuperfan
Brian37's picture
Posts: 13768
Joined: 2006-02-14
User is onlineOnline
Hambydammit

Hambydammit wrote:

 

Quote:
Harris, Stegner, Hitchens, and of course those atheists who just back down and back peddle when confronted by it.

Horseshit.

I've stood in the same room with Hitchens while he said that some religious people do good things in the name of religion.  He adds the same caveat that I do -- any good that comes from religion is far outweighed by the bad.  Harris says the same things.  I don't know about Stenger, to be honest.  Could you please provide a quote from Stenger to the effect that nobody ever does anything good because of religion?

 

 

Hambi, what happend to the Clark Kent atheist I know and love? You are steeling my act! You are the good cop, and I am the bad cop.

I'm supposed to rough up the suspect and you are supposed to hold me back and say to the suspect, "I am the only friend you have".

"We are a nation of Christians and Muslims, Jews and Hindus -- and nonbelievers."Obama
Check out my poetry here on Rational Responders Like my poetry thread on Facebook under BrianJames Rational Poet also on twitter under Brianrrs37